News

Actions

Nonprofit CEO Defends Email Supporting School Board Candidates

Posted
and last updated

The President and CEO of a major Nashville nonprofit organization was accused of encouraging her employees of supporting certain candidates running for the Metro Nashville School Board. 

Marsha Edwards of the Martha O'Bryan Center, an 501(c)(3) organization, sent out an email on June 23 to everyone on her contact list. The email started out saying there is an urgent need for paid canvassers that would help the campaigns of four candidates. 

According to the Internal Revenue Service, 501(c)(3) organizations are absolutely prohibited from directly or indirectly participating in, or intervening in, any political campaign on behalf of (or in opposition to) any candidate for elective public office. 

"Nonprofits that are tax deductible should be very careful about how they are involved with political activity," President of Center for Nonprofit Management Lewis Levine told NewsChannel 5.

Nonprofits and its donors are granted tax exemptions but Levine said an IRS investigation could be detrimental.

"The nuclear option would be the removal of the nonprofit status by the IRS," Levine added. "A nonprofit can't exist without a tax exempt status."

Jane Meneely, Miranda Christy, Jackson Miller and Thomas Druffel were all listed in the email as being endorsed by Stand For Children, a political action committee with an office in Nashville. 

The committee supports candidates that are friendly to charter schools. 

Stand For Children Nashville City Director Daniel O'Donnell asked for help endorsing the candidates through knocking on doors and making phone calls. Anyone willing to help would get paid $10 an hour. He said in the email, "To put it bluntly: we are being outworked by our opponents, putting us on a losing trajectory."

Edwards suggested that the center's college students and grads should participate in the canvassing. She even said that two of the candidates, one of which already works for the nonprofit as an event consultant, would be strong members. 

According to its tax form, the center easily gets millions of dollars in contributions.

Metro spends at least 100-thousand dollars each year to support the center.

School board candidates feel the email was unfair including District 5 candidate Christiane Buggs.

"It's becoming harder and harder to run an authentic grassroots campaign," Buggs, a former teacher said. "It would be a great chance to have extra volunteers."

She added that a charter school candidate is being backed is frustrating.

Marsha Edwards released a statement:

"Today’s story in The Tennessean references an email I forwarded to employees of The Martha O’Bryan Center for an opportunity to work as a paid canvasser in the upcoming School Board election, so that it could be passed on to students in our programs or anyone in our organization looking for paid work this summer. I felt that this was an employment opportunity for young people and we would pass along this type of opportunity for ANY candidate and will continue to do so.  I added to the email what knowledge I had of the few candidates that I had met and the organization that was hiring.  While I have been assured by our legal counsel that this email did not constitute “political activity” as defined by the IRS, I do see how the personal context included in the email could be misunderstood, and I truly regret that."  
 
"The Martha O’Bryan Center does not engage in political activity and our track record supports that.  We are an organization that has been serving the Nashville community for over 120 years and continues to do so without political bias.  At Martha O’Bryan we are about breaking the line of poverty through education, employment and family support, not politics."