Talk Of The Town


Hugh-Baby's Famous Comeback Sauce

Posted at 12:12 PM, Aug 24, 2020
and last updated 2020-08-24 13:12:08-04

Pat Martin of Hugh-Baby's BBQ and Burger Shop made Hugh Baby's famous Comeback Sauce - the secret ingredient that makes Hugh Baby's burgers so special. Hugh-Baby's BBQ and Burger Shop has 3 locations in the Nashville area. For more information, visit Pat also mentioned Labor Day specials happening at Martin's BBQ. For ordering information, visit

Hugh-Baby’s Comeback Sauce

1.25oz white onion - diced

24oz Duke’s Mayonnaise

6oz Ketchup

1.25oz Sweet pickle relish

.75oz Hot BBQ sauce

.5oz Cider vinegar

.25oz Dijon mustard

Pinch Black pepper

Pinch paprika

2 pinches Kosher salt


Dice onions. In a blender pulse until onions are mostly liquid. Add all other ingredients to the blender. Blend until ingredients are smooth and consistent. Refrigerate and hold for up to a month.