NewsNewsChannel 5 InvestigatesToxic School Water


Mayor Pledges To 'Look Into' NC5 Findings As Opponents Pounce

Mayor Pledges To 'Look Into' NC5 Findings As Opponents Pounce
Posted at 3:09 PM, May 23, 2018
and last updated 2018-05-23 19:34:21-04

Mayor David Briley said Wednesday he's been assured there's "no reason" to be concerned about the drinking water in Nashville schools.

However, in a clarifying statement released the night before voters go to the polls, Briley pledged to work with Metro departments "to look into the Channel 5 findings."

That reversal came after one of the top experts in the country said that, because of the way tests were conducted by Metro Schools, the results "should be thrown right in the garbage."

A NewsChannel 5 investigation discovered the district utilized a testing method that washed debris out of the pipes before the samples were collected.

Related stories:
Flint Expert: MNPS Lead Tests Belong In Garbage
MNPS Testing May Have Masked Water Contamination
Could Copper Contamination Make Students Sick?

"I have consulted with Director Scott Potter at Metro Water Services and he assures me that the water being provided to the public is safe in every respect, and there’s no reason for anyone to be concerned about exposure to lead," Briley's initial statement said in response to the story about the Flint expert.

The mayor said he would be working "to make sure the drinking water at every school remains safe."

Facing potential political blowback, the Mayor's Office issued a second statement Wednesday night that attempted to clarify his position.

"I am also working with Metro Water, Metro Schools and the Metro Public Health Department to look into the Channel 5 findings...," Briley said.

"The health and welfare of all children is at the top of my priority list."

Briley had spoken out strongly after another NewsChannel 5 investigation exposed a secret recording where a Metro Schools official discussed bypassing lead filters on school water fountains.

Mayoral candidate Carol Swain had strong words about the Metro Schools testing procedures.

"This would imply that the decision makers viewed the cost to replace the water systems is greater than negative effects on our children's health and safety," Swain's campaign said.

"If it is determined that the water system needs to be replaced, we will have to find money to repair the system.”

Ralph Bristol had a similar take.

"First, we should get a second and third opinion on the validity of the tests," Bristol wrote.

"Second, if we discover lead problems, we have to fix them, and find savings in the budget to fund the repairs."

Candidate jeff obafemi carr said "this issue hits home for me because four of my children attend a MNPS school and drink that water five days a week."

"We must elect new leadership with the ethical core to do what is necessary to protect the health and future of our city’s children, by prioritizing their safety and well-being," carr said.

State Rep. Harold Love Jr. expressed hope that new legislation requiring districts to test for lead would help clarify the issue.

Another contender, Jon Sewell, suggested the issue was "symptomatic of a greater problem."

"Inaccurate tests, failed metrics, deceptive practices are all part of the failed policies of administrative leaders looking to improve their personal lot on the backs of the collective," Sewell said.

Candidate Erica Gilmore said Metro Schools "should follow recognized best practices for lead testing."

That's why, Gilmore said, she opposes Briley's status quo budget proposal.

"As mayor, I will move heaven and earth to ensure Nashville is not the next Flint," she added.

Special Section:
NC5 Investigates: Lead in School Water